The question that I have is, simply, "Why?" Why shouldn't a 16 year old be allowed to vote? Why do we have an age limit at all? I am in college, but it is assumed that since I am young, I am also ignorant. You don't think I'm stupid because you seem to believe that in two years I will know enough to vote, but I would like to point out that there are adults that don't even know what they are voting for. I heard some statistics the other day from a survey of teens at a concert with questions like "How many senators are there?" and "Who is the Speaker of the House?" Not all that surprisingly, most teens failed miserably. However, another study was done of adults (around the age of 40 if I remember correctly) and they did only marginally better. So why does our culture assume that adults automatically know more? Along with those statistics was an article, and the main purpose was to say that if you are ignorant of the issues, you shouldn't vote.
Well, criticizing the system is useless if no solution is offered.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f1a14/f1a1400aea5dc1ccc964556d9b53c32ecd71519c" alt=""
I am not ignorant. I may not know everything, but if I had the opportunity to make my voice heard by simply learning a few more things, I would. So if someone who is capable of voting is refused a vote, does that make the election rigged? I think as a citizen of the United States of America, I should have a voice. Is that too much to ask?
Here is the catch with letting kids vote. If I told one of my kids who to vote for he/she would vote the opposite just to be difficult. Another would do exactly what I only hint is the right idea. So I tell one to vote for one candidate and one to vote for the other and I get three votes.
ReplyDeleteAt some point during the teen years, kids get better at doing their own research, but as you mentioned that is different for each kid. So you need some way to make sure that people really are voting for their own interests and not for their parent, teacher, government worker.
Why not test? It is impossible to make a test that is completely objective and universally agreed to. Make it too simple and you defeat your purpose. Too difficult and people are going to pass the test one time and fail the next time and then you get riots.
How high a score do you have to get? 70 pass, 69 no vote?
You also have to deal with cheating. For a test to be accepted it would have to be reviewed by congress which means it would be publicly accessible so if I want my kid to vote I give him/her a copy of the test and the sample ballot with all the correct answers marked... on both!
ok....valid points
ReplyDeleteany better ideas?
I still don't think it's fair that I can't vote because I'm 16....I also can't work in a shoe store or a coffee house because it's "hazardous"
I just don't understand why we bulk youth into a big group and mark it "Ignorant".....maybe I'll just have to get over it and move on.....I'll get to vote next time anyway...unless something changes